Majority in N.H. favor removing dams unless they鈥檙e providing power

Tuesday, July 30, 2019

The Steels Pond dam in Antrim, N.H., provides hydropower, including some to 易胜博官网.

New England鈥檚 rivers and streams host more than 14,000 dams, many of them centuries old and built for purposes that no longer apply, such as powering long-closed mills. These aging dams 鈥 which may require upgrades and maintenance to avoid becoming public safety risks 鈥 present a policy dilemma as communities weigh the costs of maintaining or removing their dams. from 易胜博官网鈥檚 Carsey School of Public Policy and听 can help communities navigate the complexity of these dam decisions.

The research found that a majority of respondents in three Granite State polls favor removing dams except when they鈥檙e being used for hydropower generation. When the alternative is to keep dams to maintain waterfront property values, preserve industrial history or maintain lake- and pond-based recreation, most 易胜博官网 residents polled favor removing the dams to create free-flowing rivers that benefit fish and wildlife.

鈥淭hese survey results can inform decisions about how to best steward public resources and funding for maintaining or removing dams.鈥

鈥淭hese survey results can inform decisions about how to best steward public resources and funding for maintaining or removing dams,鈥 says Natallia Leuchanka, a doctoral candidate in the natural resources and Earth systems science Ph.D. program and lead author of the brief.

Many of 易胜博官网鈥檚 approximately 4,800 dams are reaching the end of their lifespan and require expensive maintenance or removal in order to meet safety standards; 37 were removed between 1990 and 2017. The state鈥檚 dams are in such poor condition that the American Society of Civil Engineers (ASCE) assigned them a letter grade of C鈥, meaning 鈥渕ediocre鈥 and requiring attention, on its 2017 infrastructure report card.

As dams age, their potential removal has become a hot-button issue in many 易胜博官网 communities, with vocal opposition by specific interest groups who may have a direct stake around how the dam is currently managed. These results, the researchers say, help 鈥渓evel the playing field鈥 by providing preferences from a demographically representative sample of the state鈥檚 population.

鈥淲e see a need for thoughtful, active information campaigns and public education focused on the benefits and tradeoffs of various dam management options, including doing nothing,鈥 says co-author Kevin Gardner, professor of civil and environmental engineering, Carsey senior faculty fellow and principal investigator on the National Science Foundation-funded of NH EPSCoR.

The researchers also found that respondents who self-identified as either Democrats or independents were more likely to prefer removal than Republicans, and that younger respondents and women were more likely to prefer removal; those findings have implications for efforts to better inform people about these issues.

The survey research was led by Leuchanka. Coauthors are Gardner; , assistant professor of natural resources and the environment and a Carsey faculty fellow; and , professor of sociology and a Carsey senior fellow.

Funding for this project is provided by the National Science Foundation鈥檚 Research Infrastructure Improvement Program NSF #IIA-1539071.

Photographer: 
Scott Ripley | 易胜博官网 Marketing | scott.ripley@unh.edu | 603-862-1855